By now I wonder, how many Christmas carols have you listened to? Not time amount, but how many actual Christmas songs could you name if we took the time to list them this morning?
In my kitchen as Emma and I baked and prepared meals together, we routinely asked our virtual assistant, and I won’t say their names for fear of whose listening on YouTube, “so and so play some traditional Christmas music.” And then I enjoyed smoking chicken drumsticks and baking pies. Emma made bread and yeast rolls. We mashed potatoes and prepared deviled eggs while one of us sang—and it wasn’t Emma who sang.
Yes, as early as Thanksgiving Day, we did this with Jennifer tasting our work to make sure we weren’t messing anything up. Amazon’s virtual assistant in the kitchen, and Apple’s in the Den, they were our DJ cycling through all the classics that you could think of. . . even the Grinch.
So again, I wonder if you’ve joined me in this practice of enjoying everything from White Christmas to Joy to the World to… whatever your favorite Christmas carol or song is? Don’t say them out loud now either.
But as you listened to these selections, whether out in packed stores or at home like me, did you ever hear a message like the one from Matthew 3? Did you hear of John the Baptizer in those songs or consider the potency of what John said to his assembled congregation by the Jordan River?
Every year the church reads about John the Baptist at some point in our Advent journey. Every year, we pause to consider how John helps us to prepare ourselves for the birth of Jesus. And while you might be tempted to think that John’s message is out of place among Christmas lights and the joy of the holiday season, this message is important because it speaks to the orientation of our hearts.
Move 1- The difference
While the first three gospels all speak about John, it is only Matthew who gives us the potency of, “Produce fruit in keeping with repentance.” Mark barely touches the message of John and Luke gives us more depth to the message; it is Matthew who provides the passion that we all remember. Matthew makes the difference. Matthew challenges us in the Christmas season to examine our lives, honestly, and fully.
And after we examine our lives, after we look ourselves fully and notice the places where we fall short… our response becomes clear, we should repent.
The language Matthew uses in this place/moment is stark.
“Repentance, or metanoia, to use the Greek word, refers to far more than a simply being or saying one is sorry for past sins, far more than mere regret or remorse for such sins. It refers to a turning away from the past way of life and the inauguration of a new one, in this case initialized by an act of baptism.[1]”
Everyone likes to say, ‘sorry about that. Didn’t mean to say that or do that.’ But biblical repentance. The type of repentance that Matthew’s John is preaching to his congregation in today’s text, is one that calls out a deep, meaningful, reflection and analysis—a deep response.
The message from John the Baptist that we read in Matthew’s gospel wants each person who comes to the Jordan, and each follower of Christ who reads this message later, and each members of the church in Advent now, to pause, make deliberate space in their day, and consider how their lives have not lined up to how God calls them to live.
And while this does not feel like a message suited to, ‘Have a holly, jolly, Christmas, cause it’s the best time of the year,’ perhaps this is exactly the right message that the Church who will silently come to the manger needs to hear and consider.
Perhaps the reading of Matthew 3 makes all the difference as Advent begins this year—even if it seems to feel out of place.
Move 2- Jesus makes that difference.
For as we make the space to repent, we draw ourselves close to the Lord. . . and in our drawing close to the Lord, we notice something happening around us in our relationship with God.
Jesus has draws himself close to us in response before we could even begin our movement toward him. Jesus will choose us and, in His choice, we are blessed, changed, and ultimately forgiven. And John’s message foreshadows this choice of our Savior in verse 11 even if Jesus has not walked onto the stage of life yet for us, we can hear and feel Him drawing close to us.
“But he who is coming after me is mightier than I, whose sandals I am not worthy to carry. He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and with fire.’”[2]
You see, even with the potency of John’s fiery message to repent, we cannot lose track of Jesus and the forgiveness that comes in Him to those who spend the time, engage in the work of repentance, and turn fully to Jesus. No justification offered. Just presence and honestly before the Lord. Not judgement and separation, just unity with the one who heals us when we are honest with him.
For the Christian experience of forgiveness can be something wonderful… if we are honest with the Lord about who we are and how we have fallen short. As we embrace the presence of Jesus ‘with us’ the miracle has space to take that potency from John and work its own miracle of healing in our lives.
William Muehl tells this story that underlines the presence that is possible in this moment. Rather than experiencing separation in our repentance, or placation, even in the pain that these actions can present, we can find peace and unity with the Lord if we linger and notice what is happening.
“One December afternoon. . . a group of parents stood in the lobby of a nursery school waiting to claim their children after the last pre-Christmas class session. As the youngsters ran from their lockers, each one carried in [their] hands the ‘surprise,’ the brightly wrapped package on which [they] had been working diligently for weeks. One small boy, trying to run, put on his coat, and wave to his parents, all at the same time, slipped and fell. The ‘surprise’ flew from his grasp, landed on the floor and broke with an obvious ceramic crash.
The child. . . began to cry inconsolably. His father, trying to minimize the incident and comfort the boy, patted his head and muttered, ‘Now, that’s all right, son. It doesn’t matter. It really doesn’t matter at all.’
But the boy’s mother, somewhat wiser in such situations, swept the boy into her arms and said, ‘Oh, but it does. It matters a great deal.’ And she wept with her son.”[3]
This story illustrates that the church has a responsibility to come together and remind each other that the pain that we feel as we examine our sin and our short comings, it matters so much to God and to each other. Let us not minimize this moment but embrace it.
This moment is not about judgment and/or the separation that comes when we confess or sins. But rather, as the mother took her son in her arms in solidarity, Jesus takes us up in his arms, and He weeps with us as we realize how sinful we are as we abide in God’s presence. He does not pat us on the head and brush us on our way. . .R Rather Jesus, holds us close as we realize how deeply our sin cuts us and wounds our relationship with God and with each other.
In this way, the potency of John’s message that calls us to repent, calls us to examine ourselves faithfully and fully, and with all the sting that we read about in the text today, it meets the grace of God in the person of Jesus who is with us and who comes to the Jordan to meet John in the gospel, and whose birth we celebrate this season, and He weeps with us as we confess that sin fully.
Conclusion
As we prepare to install and ordain Ruling Elders for the class of 2028 and place them in leadership at this church, I hope the message of John will stick with them, and with you.
This is not a word that is only to be considered once a year, but it should remain in our hearts and lives. For each day, we need to make the space and create the time to recall John and his message. We need to wonder about where the places and the moments are where we need to repent… and more than just repent, where do we need to extend forgiveness and feel that extension in our lives.
For that practice must extend outside of this space and this moment. It must be carried with us from here and touch the lives of others in this community. For Christ was born for all of us.
[1] https://www.workingpreacher.org/commentaries/revised-common-lectionary/second-sunday-of-advent/commentary-on-matthew-31-12
[2] Matthew 3:11 ESV
[3] Feasting on the Word Year A. Volume 1. Page 46.